Custom cakes, cookies & cupcakes, baked to order in Lexington, SCPickup by arrangement · Email cinnamonrlarkin@gmail.com

How Much Cake Do I Need? A Party Dessert Guide

A quick guide to sizing desserts by headcount, plus tips for getting buttercream through a South Carolina summer. Slice counts are typical party-size servings; Cinnamon will recommend a size for your order.

Party Guide

Up to 12 guests

Family dinner or small birthday

  • A small round cake (6-inch is about 12 party slices)
  • Or a dozen cupcakes
  • Add a dozen cookies as take-home treats
15–25 guests

Classroom or backyard party

  • An 8-inch round is about 24 party slices
  • Or two dozen cupcakes ($50)
  • A dozen cake pops for the kids' table ($24)
30–40 guests

Showers and milestone birthdays

  • A 10-inch round is about 38 party slices
  • Or a smaller cake plus two dozen cupcakes
  • Brownies or cookies stretch the dessert table
50+ guests

Church, school and office events

  • Cookies and cupcakes are the easiest to serve
  • Plan on 1–2 cookies per guest
  • Send your headcount and Cinnamon will help size it

Keeping buttercream happy in South Carolina heat

Buttercream softens quickly in a Midlands summer. A few habits keep your cake looking the way it did at pickup:

  • Ride flat and cool. Set the box on a flat floorboard or trunk floor, not a slanted seat, and run the air conditioning before you load it.
  • Go straight home. A parked car heats up fast. Make the bakery your last stop.
  • Keep it inside until serving time. Outdoor parties are hard on buttercream. Keep the cake in air conditioning and bring it out when it's time to sing.
  • Choose travel-friendly treats for the lake or a tailgate. Cookies and cupcakes hold up far better than a tall layer cake on a hot dock.

What to send with your order

The custom order form asks for everything Cinnamon needs to plan your treats. Having these ready makes it quick:

  • Your pickup or event date, and whether you need pickup or delivery
  • What you'd like (cake, cupcakes, cookies or a mix) and roughly how many guests
  • Your occasion, theme and color palette
  • Inspiration: a Pinterest or Instagram link, or photos you can attach when Cinnamon emails you back
  • Flavor preference, dietary needs and every allergy
  • A budget, if you have one in mind

Not sure how much to order? Put your headcount in the order and Cinnamon will recommend a size. You can see every starting price on the menu & prices page.

FAQ

Party dessert questions

How many cupcakes should I order per guest?

Plan on about one cupcake per guest, and a few extra for big eaters or second rounds. Two dozen covers most classroom and backyard parties.

How many cookies per person for an event?

One to two cookies per guest works for most events. For a dessert table with other sweets, one each is usually plenty.

How do I keep a buttercream cake from melting outside?

Keep it in air conditioning until serving time, out of direct sun, and transport it flat and cool. For outdoor events, cookies and cupcakes hold up better.

Tell Cinnamon your headcount

Send your date and guest count with your order and she'll recommend the right size.